The so-called "white coat effect" of doctors on blood pressure readings has now been confirmed in a scientific study, researchers say today.
The effect – the stress of being examined – is thought to lead to many patients showing exaggerated readings of blood pressure.
Dr Christopher Clark of Exeter University, UK and his team carried out a systematic review of blood pressure readings taken from 1,019 individuals who were checked by both a doctor and a nurse at the same visit. Readings taken by doctors were significantly higher, by 7/4mmHg, than readings taken by nurses.
"Our results were pooled from different settings across ten countries, so we can be confident that they can be generalised to any healthcare environment where blood pressure is being measured," said Dr Clark. "These results were all from research trials our next task will be to examine data from GP surgeries."
The review is published today (26 March) in the British Journal of General Practice.
Dr Clark believes the findings should lead to changes in clinical practice. He says: "Doctors should continue to measure blood pressure as part of the assessment of an ill patient or a routine check-up, but not where clinical decisions on blood pressure treatment depend on the outcome.
"The difference we noted is enough to tip some patients over the threshold for treatment for high blood pressure, and unnecessary medication can lead to unwanted side-effects.
"Some patients may be erroneously asked to continue to monitor their own blood pressure at home, which can build anxiety. These inappropriate measures could all be avoided by the simple measure of someone other than a doctor taking the blood pressure recording."
He added that researchers need to consider this effect in studies of blood pressure. For example, some studies have concluded that nurses are better at treating hypertension, which may not actually be the case.
Clark, C. et al. British Journal of General Practice 26 March 2014

Leave a Reply