Expert voices concern over ‘polypill hype’

The world is facing "polypillomania" as companies rush to develop a single pill to prevent heart disease, an expert warned today.

The idea is that a single pill will contain a statin to tackle cholesterol, aspirin, and other drugs, such as an angiotensin-converting enzyme inhibitor and a beta blocker or a thiazide diuretic.

Writing in the Drug and Therapeutics Bulletin, editor Dr Ike Iheanacho says that ever since the concept of the polypill was introduced, "it has maintained an almost magical hold over the lay press and many health care professionals".

But Dr Iheanacho questions whether the concept of a polypill deserves such hype. Although the argument in favour of a single pill to reduce the risk of heart disease is seductive, the reality is not so straightforward, he says.

Firstly, trials are being carried out on a range of different polypills that target different patient populations, differ in the types and doses of drugs they include and measure different outcomes.

"The original concept of a simple solution to a common problem has mutated into testing an increasingly complex range of potential products for multiple patient populations," he writes.

What’s more, the trial results often do not answer the basic question of how well the polypills work compared with standard treatment in improving long-term heart health, he says. Instead they concentrate on short-term effects on cholesterol or blood pressure.

"As things stand, it’s hard to see justification for the largely uncritical coverage that is given to the polypill, an idea in danger of becoming a solution that’s desperately seeking a problem, rather than the other way round," writes Dr Iheanacho.

His comments come after the announcement in January of a new polypill trial at Queen Mary, University of London, UK, involving healthy participants aged over 50.

Iheanacho, I. Polypillomania. Drug and Therapeutics Bulletin, Vol. 49, February 2011.

, ,

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Search

Categories

Monthly Posts

Our Clients

BSH
Practice Index